Almost ten years after "Mr. Brightside" helped turn
the Killers into new millennial rock sensations, the time has come for a hits collection. Calling the compilation
Direct Hits -- a punning title that feels timeless but has rarely been used before, a nifty encapsulation of the group's style and attributes --
the Killers cannily use the singles-centric conceit to showcase the band at their overblown best, emphasizing their arena-sized neo-new wave just slightly over their
Springsteenisms. Both are on display on the two new songs -- "Shot at the Night" and "Just Another Girl," songs that sound as if
U2,
Springsteen, and
the Cars created a supergroup in 1988 -- but the main benefit of
Direct Hits, especially for those listeners who have always doubted the skills of
the Killers, is how the operatic ambitions of
Sam's Town feel not so extravagant when bookended by selections from Day & Age and Battle Born. All three of the albums -- which are represented by three cuts a piece -- sound strong here but what really has lasted are those singles from 2004's
Hot Fuss, especially the initial breakthroughs "Mr. Brightside" and "All These Things That I've Done," which now seem to capture a particular moment in time and yet also transcend it. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine