Railroad Earth, the string band from New Jersey that has amassed a following in the Rocky Mountains, has made three studio albums. But the real test of a jam band, of course, is its live work, and
Elko,
Railroad Earth's fourth release, is the inevitable double-CD concert album. The sextet has an instrumentation that suggests bluegrass -- an acoustic guitarist, a violinist, a mandolin player, a multi-instrumentalist who plays banjo and Dobro among other things, and a rhythm section of acoustic bass and drums. But it is not shy about using amplification so that the stringed instruments can be heard over the drums, or effects more typical of an electrified ensemble. Thus, the guitar solos that decorate "The Hunting Song," "Head," and "Warhead Boogie" may be played on an acoustic instrument in the technical sense, but they sure sound electric, and the music makes use of echo and other forms of sound manipulation. Still, the overall effect retains a modified acoustic feel. It isn't hard to imagine what records these musicians have on their shelves, say
Workingman's Dead and
American Beauty by
the Grateful Dead,
Rubber Soul by
the Beatles,
John Wesley Harding by
Bob Dylan, and
Music from Big Pink and
The Band by
the Band, and throw in recordings by
New Grass Revival and
the Rowan Brothers, plus, perhaps,
the Waterboys'
Fisherman's Blues. Lead singer and primary songwriter
Todd Sheaffer particularly suggests
the Waterboys' Mike Scott in his nasal tenor, which listeners also may hear as resembling
Arlo Guthrie,
Tom Petty, or
Rodney Crowell. The question of whether or not
Railroad Earth can jam, if it were really in doubt, is swiftly answered on a 126-minute collection of 12 songs, five of which run over ten minutes each. If there is any discordance in the band's music, it is between
Sheaffer, whose songs, with their soul-searching lyrics, sound like singer/songwriter fare, and the rest of the group, which sometimes swamps those songs with their extended, exploratory improvising. The four string players achieve an instrumental cohesion that suggests bluegrass, while the rhythm section throws in occasional world music elements -- a Jamaican reggae beat here, a Celtic, African, or Middle Eastern cadence there. Repeating eight songs from the band's previous studio efforts,
Elko sums up where
Railroad Earth has been and suggests where it's going. Of course, it also makes a terrific invitation to see them live. ~ William Ruhlmann