Music from the Motion Picture is the first album of new music from
10,000 Maniacs in 14 years and, as perhaps could be expected, a lot has happened over that decade-and-a-half. First of all, founding member
Robert Buck died of liver failure in 2000; secondly
John Lombardo -- another founding member who also often functioned as the musical partner of
Mary Ramsey, who has been the
Maniacs' lead singer ever since the 1993 departure of
Natalie Merchant -- left in 2002 and didn't rejoin when the group re-formed in 2008. The current lineup comprises
Ramsey, keyboardist
Dennis Drew, bassist
Steve Gustafson, and drummer Jerry Augustyniak, a trio that has been in place since 1983, and guitarist Jeff Erickson, who came on board after
Buck's passing, so this is a band with a long history and a comfortable chemistry that's readily apparent on
Music from the Motion Picture. Indeed, many casual listeners could spin this 2013 album and be none the wiser of all the lineup shifts (indeed,
Ramsey can sometimes sound like
Merchant). Much of the album sounds even closer to prime Bush-era
Maniacs than 1999's The Earth Pressed Flat: it's clean, gentle, and melodic, mellowed jangle pop that's always sweet, never melancholy. If the album is never exactly compelling, it never tries to be, either: it's comfort music for Gen-X'ers, usually sure-footed (it stumbles only toward the end, when the reggae lilt of "It's a Beautiful Life" is paired with the fussily moody "Fine Line"), and sure to satisfy those who are looking for something that sounds like
Blind Man's Zoo with a fresh coat of paint. ~ Stephen Thomas Erlewine