Some conductors regard Carl Nielsen's six powerful symphonies as problems, to be solved largely through interpretive means; the rough melodic edges, unusual harmonic spacings, and quirky instrumental combinations that are so characteristic of these unique works are too often played down, smoothed over, and blended away, as if they were surface flaws on otherwise conventional post-Romantic works. Once in a while, though, a sympathetic conductor takes these symphonies at face value and recognizes that Nielsen intended that everything he put in his scores, albeit idiosyncratic, should be heard clearly and without compromises.
Theodore Kuchar's 2006 set with the
Janácek Philharmonic Orchestra is one of the most accomplished Nielsen cycles around, and the details of the music are so clear that nothing is left to speculation. The dimensions of the orchestra's sound are deep, the frequency range is wide, and the acoustics of the Ostrava Concert Hall are naturally responsive, so conditions are nearly ideal for
Kuchar's unadulterated and utterly transparent readings. The results are direct, forceful, and sometimes searing in their intensity; and since there are no balance issues in the performances to distract the listener, the emotional impact of the music is every bit as strong as the composer intended. Though issued at a budget price, Brilliant's recordings are first rate, and this three-CD package holds its own against any of the major-label sets available.