There have been a whole lot of ill-conceived orchestra/rock hybrids, ranging from
the Beatles to
Yes to Creed(!), and, as a general rule, they live up to their low expectations. Then there's the occasional rocker bidding for 'serious music' consideration, like
Ian Anderson,
Paul McCartney and
Billy Joel, who never quite get the desired recognition despite all the hoopla surrounding the release.
Frank Zappa's orchestral version of "Duke of Prunes" from
Orchestral Favorites is probably the most successful integration of orchestra and electric guitar, but one tune only hints at the potential. It doesn't mean that the concept is without merit, it just shows that no one with the talent and vision to pull off a full program has made an attempt thus far. Until now.