Arriving three years after their big 2017 comeback,
Acceptance's third full-length
Wild, Free pushes the band's impassioned, hook-friendly sound into the tear-soaked territory of a classic breakup album. Like fellow scene vets
Jimmy Eat World, they retain their early-aughts emo-rock heart while embracing their power-pop tendencies and love of the '80s, resulting in a sharp set of melodic anthems steeped in heartache. Tightly focused on the disintegration of a relationship,
Wild, Free is fraught with emotion, touching upon the hurt, desperate bargaining, and, ultimately, bittersweet resignation that comes with a difficult split. Whether comparing love to a battlefield ("Cold Air") or longing for the halcyon early days ("Wasted Nights"), frontman
Jason Vena backs his powerful delivery with some of the most evocative lyrics in the band's catalog, unfurling late-night scenes and dark moments of loneliness, when overthinking and overanalyzing can cripple even the strongest spirit. Opener "Midnight" sets the stage for heartbreak: atop shimmering synths,
Vena's wounded vocals tremble to life, before the band kicks into full throttle with
Garrett Lunceford's drums and
Ryan Zwiefelhofer's bass barreling forward through a thick wall of guitar courtesy of
Kaylan Cloyd and
Christian McAlhaney. It's a classic
Acceptance moment, but with years of refinement since 2005's
Phantoms, "Midnight" reaches the epic arena levels of
U2 and
the Killers. Echoes of the latter group appear throughout, especially in the rollicking delivery of the urgent "Release and Let Go"; the harmonies of the impassioned duet with Nashville-based singer
Jessie Villa, "Wildfires"; and the expanded scope of the soaring closer, "At the Edge of the Earth." Although there's enough on
Wild, Free to crush even the hardest of hearts, the album reaches its peak of grief on the sparse "Bend the Light," a devastating moment that swells with sparkling atmospherics and restrained piano as
Vena tenderly pleads, "I'm trying to keep us together/Will you help me?" Much like
Coldplay's similarly wounded
Ghost Stories,
Wild, Free is
Acceptance's most personal album to date, an unflinching journey through anguish and memory that is as vulnerable as it is catchy. ~ Neil Z. Yeung