There are a number of arguments to be made for and against
Maria Muldaur's 2008 antiwar statement
Yes We Can! on Telarc (before actually listening to it; remember, we live in a cynical culture). The "perceived" negatives all relate to the intent of the recording and who it's supposed to reach (no doubt an expression of the same set of beliefs rooted in
Muldaur's 1960s music), and the fact that it's loaded with guests (in all fairness, these star-studded affairs seldom work). On
Yes We Can!, her guests include
Muldaur's old friends (
Joan Baez,
Bonnie Raitt,
Phoebe Snow,
Jane Fonda, and
Holly Near) and influences (
Odetta) and new pals (writers/spiritual gurus Anne Lamott and
Marianne Williamson, and Indian spiritual teacher Amma). Does it read as if it is yet another exercise in self-referential backslapping? Yep. But don't believe everything you read on the back of a CD jacket. The positives are all musical. First off,
Muldaur hasn't sounded this funky in years -- if ever! The set was co-produced by
Muldaur and
Joel Jaffe. The sound is, for the most part, dirty, raw, and angular, ranging from deep Southern blues to Cajun, gospel, rhythm & blues, and soul -- no matter where the songs come from originally. Her great influence,
Memphis Minnie, would have been proud of
Muldaur's use of the Southern inflection that sounds unaffected even though she was born in New York. Credit for the sonics falls equally with the production and arrangements (handled heroically by
David Torkanowsky) and the musicianship (
the Free Radicals and the Women's Voices for Peace Choir). The track selection is killer to boot:
Edwin Starr's "War (What Is It Good For),"
Allen Toussaint's title track,
Bob Dylan's "License to Kill" and "Masters of War,"
Garth Brooks' beautiful "We Shall Be Free" (with deeply moving solo spots from her guests), Elbernita Terrell's (from Detroit's wonderful gospel group
the Clark Sisters) "Pray for the USA," and the traditional "Down by the Riverside." Of the two
Dylan tracks, "License to Kill" rivals the original.
Muldaur understates the lyric, bringing out its nuances and the hidden power in the melody.
Muldaur's reading of
Timmy Thomas' "Why Can't We Live Together" drips with sincerity and is delivered with expert control -- she's a true craftswoman as a vocalist, always resisting the temptation to over-sing. That said,
Muldaur may have lost her "good girl gone bad" seductiveness of the early '70s, but what she replaces it with is far more sultry because there isn't anything here but the desire to communicate the emotional intention of these songs in her husky, deeply soulful voice. Old hippies may be drawn to this set for its guests and track list, but any fan of bona fide, honestly performed, deeply emotional American music will be knocked out by it as well. ~ Thom Jurek