The formula behind
the Carpenters' albums was starting to get fairly routine -- a hit single and an oldie or two (which sometimes was the single) surrounded by some well-produced soft pop/rock, driven by electric piano, strings, and a guitar solo or two cropping up. "There's a Kind of a Hush" and "Breaking Up Is Hard to Do" are the two most memorable tracks on this pleasant, well-sung, and well-played, but basically bland, album, A Kind of Hush. There are virtues here -- "You" has a good guitar solo by Tony Peluso, and the vocals on "Sandy" are radiant, but this record was where the real rot began to set into
the Carpenters' fortunes, in terms of remaining connected to rock. Instead of covering
Leon Russell's or
Carole King's contemporary material, they're doing songs like "Can't Smile Without You" -- the latter is very sweetly sung by
Karen Carpenter, and gets a lyrical but spare arrangement from
Richard Carpenter, but they needed something more credible to the under-30 audience (and especially material that, if not attractive to guys in that age range, at least wouldn't make them self-conscious about listening to it with their girlfriends) on this album, and it wasn't here. If you close your eyes, it's possible to imagine
Captain & Tennille, not to mention
Debby Boone, taking lessons from this release, although
Karen's voice was still beyond comparison with any of them. ~ Bruce Eder