With
Armchair Apocrypha,
Andrew Bird takes another developmental departure from his previous works, though not nearly in as drastic a fashion as his previous album-to-album jumps in style. This has become expected of
Bird and is one of the merits that make each of his releases highly anticipated. Where in the past
Bird has impressed listeners with his violin artistry and vocal delivery, and later his use of electronic looping and whistling, with
Armchair he allows the songs to breathe more on their own, using the aforementioned elements to blend into the structural integrity of the songs rather than predominately featuring each component. This is not to say his previous approaches were ineffective, but rather an observation that is one of the essential reasons
Armchair Apocrypha holds together more cohesively than
Bird's previous outings. Perhaps the heavy inclusion of drummer and electric pianist
Martin Dosh has much to do with this cohesion; it is the first time
Dosh and
Bird have teamed up on a recording, though the two had been touring together with regularity for a couple of years previous to this.
Dosh provides excellent propulsion as a drummer and his Rhodes/Wurlitzer playing adds a deep and dynamic warmth to the entire album. With a few other guests, most noticeably bassist
Chris Morrissey's playing on five of the 12 tracks,
Armchair is the first album since the 2001 release of
The Swimming Hour that feels like a band playing together rather than songs built in separate layers.
The majority of the album feels so much more relaxed than much of
Bird's previous works, due much in part to his almost laconic vocal delivery throughout. It's the first album that captures
Bird's much lauded live approach, almost as if he had hit some completely transcendental place mentally, forgotten his place in the studio, and instead just sang while in some distant reverie -- the way one sings unencumbered while washing the dishes in an empty house and, unknowingly, hones his artistic blade cleaning dirty knife by dirty knife. The most excellent example of this delivery is on the majestically sprawling "Armchairs," a complex and dynamic number that unfolds cinematically in that it entirely captures attention and does not relent through nearly seven minutes, even without a single repeating melody. It is only fitting, then, that in the first climax of "Armchairs,"
Bird belts out, "Time, it's a crooked bow!" over a dramatic musical descent. And he's right, the seven minutes in which "Armchairs" unfolds are so captivating, the time feels cut in half. That said, the entirety of
Armchair Apocrypha does not completely have that level of looseness and adventure. "Imitosis," a reworked version of "I" from the 2003 release Weather Systems, holds some of the stiffness of
Bird's previous recordings which, to be fair, did not seem so stiff before
Armchair Apocrypha was released. Still, as likeable a revision as "Imitosis" is, the song feels somewhat out of place alongside the bulk of these tracks and, being the second album in a row where
Bird has updated a song from Weather Systems ("Skin Is, My" from The Mysterious Production of Eggs was an update of "Skin" from Weather Systems), it is hard not to begin listening to his back catalog searching for possibly half-baked ideas. This feeling generally dissipates when listening to songs such as "Armchairs," the undeniably catchy "Plasticities" (that
Bird's delivery of the chorus' lyric "We'll fight..." sounds like "Whale fight..." only makes the song more endearing), or the drum-loop based "Simple X," co-written by
Dosh, but is notable enough to contemplate whether or not
Bird was confident in his previous albums or simply felt inspired to remake the past.
It would be negligent not to mention the careful engineering and mixing that so clearly went into the making of
Armchair Apocrypha, as it is, sonically, the most pleasing work not only that
Bird has done, but that has come out in some time. The guitars and electric pianos are decidedly rich in tone and though at any given moment there are endless shifting layers of vocals, violins, guitars and more,
Armchair Apocrypha never feels cluttered. Certainly, this is due in part to the exceptional arrangements, but also credit is due to the wonderful placement of the instruments in the mix throughout the recording. This, in part with the further adventurous nature of
Bird's developments as a songwriter and performer make
Armchair Apocrypha the finest recording he has made to date, an impressive achievement considering his remarkable catalog thus far. ~ Gregory McIntosh