If Yeah was the sound of
the Wannadies getting bad blood out of their system, then
Before and After is its joyous, carefree follow-up, a record as free and uninhibited as the last weeks of June, when the promise of the entire summer still lies ahead. Well, mostly anyway --
the Wannadies haven't completely abandoned their demons, as a song like "Piss on You" shows -- but this is basically a happier
Wannadies than the last time out. So why does it feel so hollow?
Before and After was marked by a slightly difficult birth -- initially conceived as a "concept" double album in which the first disc was "go out and party" music and the second was mellow "come down" music, the project was trimmed down to a single disc. The concept stuck, though, as the first half a dozen songs (the "before" half) are, as they said, the "party" songs, and the latter half ("after") are mostly reflective ballads. The problem is that
the Wannadies seem to be in somewhat of a songwriting rut. While there was evidence of this on Yeah, they covered it up with walls of strings, disco beats, and
T. Rex-style glam rock, but on
Before and After the style is more warts and all, exposing that their hooks simply aren't quite as strong this time out. That doesn't mean this is a failure -- a decent
Wannadies album is better than most guitar pop bands' best works -- and many of the tunes here, like "Skin," "Piss on You," and "Little By Little" rank as
Wannadies classics. But as an album,
Before and After falls a bit behind. Maybe it's better to view it as a collection of two conceptually related EPs -- which is fair, and even more or less accurate -- and on that level, it's at least an interesting experiment. ~ Jason Damas