For adult contemporary R&B fans, it was disheartening that a vocalist as talented as
Leela James went almost four years before releasing a follow-up to her flawed but promising debut. Coming into her second album with the knowledge that it is part of the Shanachie label's extensive series of all-covers sets, predominantly the province of artists twice
James' age who are on album number ten or 20 instead of two, gauging the level of expectations is tricky. On one hand, it is frustrating that
James' second album, after all this time, contains no original songs; on the other, it should be a loose, no-fuss affair, less measured than
A Change Is Gonna Come and more like
James' well-regarded live show. The latter, thankfully, is very much true.
James' selections are mostly inspired, containing some natural (if obvious) material -- like the album's bookends,
Betty Wright's "Clean Up Woman" and
the Staple Singers' "Let's Do It Again" -- and some others that are bound to raise some eyebrows, just from seeing the titles.
Womack & Womack's gently swinging "Baby I'm Scared of You" is a highlight, despite the absence of a sparring partner, which lends it a tone that is more serious than
the Womacks' typically playful original.
Phyllis Hyman's "You Know How to Love Me," perhaps the boldest inclusion (written and recorded when
Mtume/Lucas and
Hyman were at the peak of their powers), gets a faithful look, proving that
James should do free-spirited and uptempo material more often. "I'd Rather Be with You" (
Bootsy's Rubber Band) could use more sleaze and
Bobby Womack's "Nobody Knows You When You're Down and Out" lacks some necessary unease, and it would have been a nice twist for
James to tackle something from the last 25 years, but overall,
Let's Do It Again is one of Shanachie's best all-covers discs. May
James find a support system that allows her to record albums of new material every other year (or so) from here on out. ~ Andy Kellman