Television were generally regarded as the precise and arty guys of the original New York punk scene -- enough so that some have (rather pointlessly) questioned just what they had to do with the punk rock aesthetic -- but while the clean lines and gleaming surfaces of
Marquee Moon and
Adventure might have inspired such thought, the band's live show told a different story. While they lacked the bash-it-out ferocity of
the Ramones or
the Dead Boys, on-stage
Television played a lot harder and looser than they did in the studio; the guitar interplay between
Tom Verlaine and
Richard Lloyd gained much grit and muscle (and
Lloyd was given significantly more space to show what he could do), and drummer Billy Ficca and Fred Smith weren't afraid to turn up the heat and add greater color and body to the songs. While the splendid "authorized bootleg"
The Blow-Up is likely to remain the definitive document of
Television's awe-inspiring live prowess,
Live at the Old Waldorf -- a professional recording of a 1978 San Francisco date on the band's last tour before their 1992 reunion -- runs a very close second, and the superior sound quality allows one to better appreciate the subtle textures lurking beneath
Verlaine and
Lloyd's Stratocaster firepower.
The Blow-Up preserves a longer and more enthusiastic performance from
Television, while
Live at the Old Waldorf finds them playing for a rather chilly away-from-home audience, but the band seems determined to show just what it can do, and these versions of "The Dream's Dream," "Little Johnny Jewel," and "Marquee Moon" are pure joy for guitar aficionados. Rhino Handmade are to be congratulated for finally giving this oft-bootlegged recording the authorized release it deserves, and providing still more evidence of
Television's enduring brilliance and innovation -- 25 years after this set was played,
Live at the Old Waldorf still sounds fresher and more exciting than most anything you're likely to see at a rock club on a given evening. ~ Mark Deming