One might assume that the difference between
Tracy Chapman's third album, which spent less than three months in the charts (and took nine years to reach gold status) after her first two albums had sold in the millions, and her fourth, which restored her to substantial commercial success, was the album's hit single, "Give Me One Reason." In fact, after a disappointing start,
New Beginning turned around and started selling a few months after its release and before the single took off. It went gold the week that "Give Me One Reason" hit the charts. Of course, having a hit single helps, too, but since "Give Me One Reason" is a nearly generic blues song that isn't particularly characteristic of
Chapman or of the album, it may have brought in an audience that didn't get what it expected. Though she has added a backup band,
Chapman continues to take a simple musical approach that focuses attention on her voice and to sing lyrics that alternate between intimate emotional portraits and broad political generalizations that seem more felt than deeply thought out. Three songs here, "Heaven's Here on Earth," "The Rape of the World," and the title cut, are about the state of the whole world, which is viewed in either excessively sunny or gloomy terms. As such,
Chapman's relationship songs, though they too can be a little vague, register more powerfully because they are so personal. As the title suggests,
Chapman is adopting a more open and hopeful posture in both her feelings and her politics on
New Beginning, and while the surprise success of "Give Me One Reason" is heartening from a career perspective, that's the real news here. ~ William Ruhlmann