Pianist and conductor
Vladimir Ashkenazy has long been associated with the music of Russian heritage, and the music of
Dmitry Shostakovich is certainly no exception. This five-disc box set, consisting primarily of previously released material, contains most of
Shostakovich's important output within his solo keyboard works and inclusive chamber music. The first three discs feature the work of
Ashkenazy exclusively. His readings of the Op. 87 Preludes and Fugues, while not always energetic, do have a profound sense of empathy and thoughtfulness, although they lack immediacy. His reasoning behind the choice of tempi in certain movements (his sluggish Prelude No. 24, for instance) also seems elusive. His rendition of the Second Piano Sonata is one of reservation, containing a mellowness that is neither readily inviting nor emotive. In contrast,
Ashkenazy performs the sometimes dreamy, sometimes jovial Three Fantastic Dances with a welcome flair that is not necessarily typical of his usual style. He also brings the irony in the composer's Aphorisms to light, and performances from the somewhat less-familiar Five Preludes and Dances of the Dolls provide enjoyable fillers for the remainder of the disc. The fourth installment begins with
Shostakovich's early, modernist First Piano Sonata. The sound world
Shostakovich creates here is similar to the styles evoked in his early Second and Third symphonies.
Lilya Zilberstein gives this tumultuous work a firmly aggressive and committed reading. It is Finnish pianist
Olli Mustonen, though, who manages to create some of the best moments in the set. His readings of the Op. 31 Preludes showcase his inviting style and wonderful lyrical gifts, including a sublimely melancholic performance of No. 10. A bleaker, more desolate atmosphere surrounds
Shostakovich's masterful Second Piano Trio, the final movement of which utilizes the haunting Jewish folk song the composer later integrated into his Eighth String Quartet. Unfortunately, the sometimes wildly swinging tempi (a result of emotional overload) only seem to distract from an otherwise superb performance courtesy of the
Beaux Arts Trio.
Ashkenazy makes an appearance on the final disc in the set, joined by a number of outstanding colleagues.
Lynn Harrell joins the pianist for an anguished performance of the cello sonata, a work that encapsulated the composer's even more-than-usually turbulent life at the time of writing (separation from his wife and more importantly, the Pravda article condemning his work). The
Fitzwilliam String Quartet, a group to whom the composer entrusted Western premieres of his last three quartets, joins
Ashkenazy for an impassioned performance of the piano quintet. While the overuse of
Ashkenazy's sometimes uninspiring performances do not necessarily make for a perfect compilation of recordings, these five discs together nevertheless form a formidable offering from Decca, containing its usual sound at a decent bargain.