Written and recorded in 1973 shortly after the death of roadie Bruce Berry,
Neil Young's second close associate to die of a heroin overdose in six months (the first was
Crazy Horse guitarist
Danny Whitten),
Tonight's the Night was
Young's musical expression of grief, combined with his rejection of the stardom he had achieved in the late '60s and early '70s. The title track, performed twice, was a direct narrative about Berry: "Bruce Berry was a working man/He used to load that Econoline van."
Whitten was heard singing "Come On Baby Let's Go Downtown," a live track recorded years earlier. Elsewhere,
Young frequently referred to drug use and used phrases that might have described his friends, such as the chorus of "Tired Eyes," "He tried to do his best, but he could not." Performing with the remains of
Crazy Horse, bassist
Billy Talbot and drummer
Ralph Molina, along with
Nils Lofgren (guitar and piano) and
Ben Keith (steel guitar),
Young performed in the ragged manner familiar from
Time Fades Away -- his voice was often hoarse and he strained to reach high notes, while the playing was loose, with mistakes and shifting tempos. But the style worked perfectly for the material, emphasizing the emotional tone of
Young's mourning and contrasting with the polished sound of
CSNY and
Harvest that
Young also disparaged. He remained unimpressed with his commercial success, noting in "World on a String," "The world on a string/Doesn't mean anything." In "Roll Another Number," he said he was "a million miles away/From that helicopter day" when he and
CSN had played Woodstock. And in "Albuquerque," he said he had been "starvin' to be alone/Independent from the scene that I've known" and spoke of his desire to "find somewhere where they don't care who I am." Songs like "Speakin' Out" and "New Mama" seemed to find some hope in family life, but
Tonight's the Night did not offer solutions to the personal and professional problems it posed. It was the work of a man trying to turn his torment into art and doing so unflinchingly. Depending on which story you believe, Reprise rejected it or
Young withdrew it from its scheduled release at the start of 1974 after touring with the material in the U.S. and Europe. In 1975, after a massive
CSNY tour,
Young at the last minute dumped a newly recorded album and finally put
Tonight's the Night out instead. Though it did not become one of his bigger commercial successes, the album was immediately recognized as a unique masterpiece by critics, and it has continued to be ranked as one of the greatest rock & roll albums ever made. ~ William Ruhlmann