Heartbreak is never any fun, but it sure seems to be good fuel for the creative process.
Nicki Bluhm first found an audience for her rich, smoky voice while making music with her husband
Tim Bluhm, who produced her early albums and co-founded their band,
the Gramblers. But in November 2015, the Bluhms revealed they were getting a divorce, and their creative partnership ended along with their marriage. Splitting up was clearly not a pleasant experience for
Nicki, and she lays out all her hurt and disappointment on her 2018 album,
To Rise You Gotta Fall. This is a breakup album if there ever were such a thing, but
Bluhm doesn't sound like the experience has weakened her. There are bittersweet moments in "Staring at the Sun" and "Last to Know" where
Bluhm reveals her emotional wounds, but more often she sounds clear-eyed in her postmortem of her relationship ("Something Really Mean") or defiant as she moves past the wreckage ("Can't Fool the Fool" and "Things I've Done"). Musically,
To Rise You Gotta Fall is steeped in vintage R&B and soul with a dash of country for seasoning, and the bluesy angles of the music are a perfect match for
Bluhm's ruminations on a love that used to be. The album was cut in Memphis at the legendary Sam Phillips Recording Studio, and producer Matt Ross-Spang has put together a band that can evoke the sounds of R&B past without sounding dated or falsely nostalgic. And
To Rise You Gotta Fall features some of
Bluhm's finest vocal work, filled with passion and nuance at the same time, and for all the powerful emotions in play here, she doesn't overplay, and the focus and restraint only make this music more intense. Hopefully
Nicki Bluhm won't have to get dumped again for her to make an album this good, but at least she found a way to put her broken heart to good use, and
To Rise You Gotta Fall ranks with her best music to date. ~ Mark Deming